A jury acquitted a St. Paul man charged in connection with the fatal shooting of a 19-year-old man in the Payne-Phalen neighborhood last winter.
The verdict came as a relief for Miklos Dates, who had been unfairly accused in the case, according to his attorney, Chris Zipko.
Dates, 24, was arrested in December 2018, a couple of weeks after three men exited a Chevrolet Cruze and shot up a vehicle parked on Payne Avenue near Geranium Avenue in what authorities said was a gang-related incident, according to court records.
Taishawn T. Smith, 19, was killed in the gunfire. A pregnant woman, also in the vehicle at the time, was struck and injured. A third passenger, also a woman, ran from the vehicle and escaped the bullets.
The Chevrolet Cruze belonged to Dates’ girlfriend, and while Zipko said his client had been with the three assailants that night, he wasn’t one of them.
He exited the vehicle to go buy cigarettes inside the New Hope Market, Zipko said, leaving Jawan Tommy Mitchell, Carlos Dillard and another man briefly behind in it.
That’s when the assailants noticed the other vehicle, with Smith inside, and started shooting, Zipko said.
Officers patrolling in the area heard the gunfire and saw three men running from the Chevrolet Cruz, and apprehended the driver, who had stayed behind.
The man said Dates, Mitchell and Dillard fled the vehicle.
Zipko contends that while his client may have run when he heard police sirens, it was actually the driver who stayed and spoke to police that was the third assailant.
He matched the description of the third shooter given to police three hours after the incident, Zipko explained, adding that the assailant was described as a tall, skinny, male with dreadlocks.
Dates is shorter with an average build and short hair.
He added that his client’s DNA wasn’t found on either of the firearms found inside the Chevrolet Cruz, though it was found on a backpack and a bag of marijuana.
DNA on one of the guns matched Mitchell, who was later identified as the primary instigator in the shooting, and the assailant who fired the most bullets. Mitchell, 19, pleaded guilty to both second-degree murder and second-degree attempted murder and was sentenced last April to about 30 years in prison.
Dillard, 20, pleaded guilty to one count of aiding and abetting second-degree murder after reaching a plea deal with the state.
Ramsey County Judge Nicole Starr sentenced him to 18 years in prison.
Dillard testified against Dates at trial, naming him as the third-shooter.
The driver found in the vehicle was never charged, Zipko said, even though he matched the description offered by the surviving victim and his DNA was found on the other handgun, along with a mixture of four other individuals.’
The prosecution contended at Dates’ trial that the driver’s fingerprint was on the gun because he handled it earlier, not because he fired it in the shooting.
Dates faced multiple charges in connection with the fatal shooting. The jury acquitted him of all the charges.
The Ramsey County Attorney’s Office declined to comment.